Skip to content

NICs follow the employment trail and not that of the paperwork

Employers pay secondary Class 1 National Insurance contributions (NICs) on their employees’ earnings, but an employer with no residence, presence or place of business in Great Britain is effectively outside the charge. Because employers’ NICs add to employment costs, some businesses try to avoid them by employing their workforce through an overseas company. One such attempt has just failed.

An anti-avoidance provision, the “host employer” rule, applies where a worker employed by a foreign employer has their personal service “made available” to a business in Great Britain and rendered for that business’s purposes. The host is then treated as the secondary contributor and must pay the employer’s NICs, whatever the contracts say. The rule considered here was the version in force before 6 April 2014, although it was later replaced by broader provisions.

The Company in question provides catering and hospitality services to North Sea offshore installations. It transferred its offshore crew to a US affiliate with no GB presence, while continuing to run the operation itself through its own offshore manual and onshore management. The First-tier Tribunal found the affiliate was little more than a contractual shell and that the Company exercised day-to-day control.

The Upper Tribunal dismissed the Company's appeal and upheld an assessment of over £6.8m, plus interest, for the period in question. Following its recent decision in Bilfinger Salamis, it held that the phrases “made available” and “rendered” require no element of control by the host. As such, it declined to depart from Bilfinger, as it was not satisfied that the decision was clearly wrong and that the Company retained the necessary control in either case.

The ruling does not, however, catch every subcontracting arrangement, and the Tribunal expressly said the outcome is sensitive to the facts. But changing who signs the employment contract will not avoid the charge where the workers’ services are in reality supplied to and used by a UK business, although this position is far from final. A renewed application for permission to appeal Bilfinger to the Court of Session was pending when judgement was given, and other Upper Tribunal appeals are outstanding, and so we may expect further deliberation. Until new light is shed upon the issue, employers would be wise not to muddy the waters by using offshore shell companies or other ghost employers.

Awards for injury to feelings are not automatic

Many might view dismissal as a ritual humiliation and seek reparations for perceived psychological damages, and so it feels natural to assume that, if a dismissal is subsequently found to be unfair, any compensation will duly reflect any personal distress caused. However, as a recent appeal found, this is seldom the case, serving as a clear reminder that an unfair dismissal award addresses actual financial loss and not injured feelings.

An unfair dismissal award has two components – the first is a "basic award", determined based on age, pay and length of service. Beyond this, there is a "compensatory award" covering any actual financial loss from the dismissal, including any lost wages and benefits until new employment is found, subject to a statutory cap.

However, any upset, anxiety or loss of self-esteem cannot be awarded as part of an unfair dismissal claim after Dunnachie v Kingston-upon-Hull City Council in 2004. The latest test case covers an individual who worked briefly as a barista in 2023. After returning from a holiday, he was abruptly dismissed, leading him to bring claims of unlawful wage deductions and unfair dismissal (although he lacked the prerequisite two years' service necessary for an ordinary claim). The tribunal decided to award him a five-figure sum for injury to feelings as part of his compensation.

However, the employer appealed and successfully argued that Dunnachie does not permit an injury-to-feelings award in an unfair dismissal case, as the lower tribunal had no discretion to award compensation for distress under such provisions.

In fact, such distress only factors into specific claims where an employee is subjected to discrimination, harassment, victimisation, or a whistleblowing detriment, irrespective of whether it eventually results in dismissal. Injury to feelings can be compensated in discrimination cases in alignment with established "Vento" bands, and such awards may be substantial. The dividing line in Dunnachie is, however, specific to the unfair dismissal regime. If there is genuine mistreatment beyond the dismissal itself, this is a separate claim and should be pleaded from the start, rather than being layered into an ongoing unfair dismissal case, where it cannot be compensated.

For employers, the upshot is that awards for injured feelings are not part of an unfair dismissal settlement, and so your organisation’s exposure is limited to the claimant's proven financial loss up to the cap. Naturally, avoiding any unnecessary grievances or deviations from employment law and the organisation’s own playbook is essential to forestalling any substantial discrimination or detriment claim, as much larger sums may be awarded.

Outsourced payroll is not a TUPE transfer: VAT ruling

A recent tribunal decision shows that calling an arrangement a “TUPE transfer” does not make it one. For accounting firms and their HR teams, the case reminds them that employment status turns on legal realities and not administrative assumptions.

A specialist engineering and inspection business with around two dozen staff had always run payroll in-house. After a key team member was absent in early 2019, it outsourced payroll to an external provider, then switched to a second. From 2019 to 2022, it reclaimed input VAT charged by these providers. It argued that its workforce had been informally transferred and that they were supplying labour back to the business. Following enquiries in 2022, HMRC denied input tax claims totalling over £500,000, and the business appealed.

The tribunal dismissed the appeal. Looking at the economic reality of the arrangement, it found that no genuine transfer of employment contracts had taken place. Contemporaneous records showed no real change, annual accounts still listed the individuals as employees, and the business continued to control its staff day to day. What the providers actually supplied was payroll administration, not labour. Although HMRC did allow recovery of VAT on the providers’ core processing fees, VAT calculated on top of net wages, salaries and National Insurance was disallowed. Thus, outsourced payroll remains a taxable service, but it cannot be used to manufacture input tax deductions from ordinary payroll costs.

The central lesson is that substance matters more than labels. Supervising staff, handling grievances, retaining dismissal rights and directing day-to-day duties are hallmarks of direct employment, whatever the paperwork says. Formalities matter too, as without executed transfer agreements, formal contract variations or proper employee consultation, employment contracts remain with the original employer, and employees cannot be moved to a new entity without their consent and documentation. Outsourcing a back-office function such as payroll does not change employment status unless there is a genuine, documented novation of contracts. Above all, written agreements, company accounts and everyday practice must tell the same story. Employers should review any arrangement where payroll or staffing is routed through a third party and check that the documentation matches how the relationship actually operates. They should also take legal advice before restructuring workforce arrangements to avoid both employment disputes and unexpected tax exposure.

Flat fees, part-time workers and the sole cause rule

A part-time private hire driver challenged a flat weekly fee his company charged for access to its booking and dispatch system. Because the fee did not vary with hours worked, part-timers paid far more per hour than full-timers for the same service. He claimed less favourable treatment because of his part-time status. The Employment Tribunal rejected the claim, finding the fee was a revenue measure and that part-time status had to be the sole reason for the treatment, with the resulting appeal leading all the way to the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court unanimously held that a part-time worker (PTW) bringing a less favourable treatment claim under the Part-Time Workers (Prevention of Less Favourable Treatment) Regulations (PTWRs) 2000 does not need to prove that part-time status was the sole reason for the treatment. It is sufficient that it was an effective cause or significantly influenced the outcome. Employers can no longer defend a policy simply by pointing to a second commercial motive, such as administrative convenience or revenue generation. Neutral-looking practices like flat fees, fixed charges and benefit rules that fall harder on part-timers are now much easier to challenge, in your own organisation and among your clients.

The successful claim rested on Regulations 5(1) and 5(2) of the PTWRs. These were made under Section 19 of the Employment Relations Act 1999 to implement Directive 97/81/EC. Under the law, PTWs must not be treated less favourably than comparable full-timers unless the treatment is objectively justified. The Court stressed that the Regulations deliberately omit the words “solely because”, so the ordinary “effective cause” approach from discrimination law applies.

To reduce your risk, review pay structures, fees and benefits for anything that costs part-timers proportionately more or gives them less, and pro-rate salary, bonuses, pensions, leave and expenses wherever possible. Where a policy does have a disproportionate effect, record the legitimate aim behind it and why it is necessary and proportionate, bearing in mind that revenue or convenience alone is unlikely to be enough. Remember that the Regulations cover workers as well as employees, so include contractors in your review. Finally, make sure HR, payroll and finance teams understand the new test, and treat any part-time grievance about pay or benefits as a potential claim by taking specialist advice early.

Ready for the October employment law changes?

Several employment law changes are approaching that businesses need to understand. The first arrives on 1 October 2026, when the normal period in which an employee can bring a claim to an Employment Tribunal increases from three months to six months.

The change has a practical consequence for employers. Employment records relating to disputes, disciplinary action and other workplace issues may remain important for longer, making accurate record keeping increasingly valuable.

Further changes follow on 30 October when employers will be required to take “all reasonable steps” to prevent sexual harassment of employees. They will also have an obligation not to permit employees to be harassed by third parties.

The changes form part of the continuing implementation of the Employment Rights Act 2025, with further measures following during 2027.

For businesses, preparation should involve more than updating the staff handbook.

Consider whether managers understand how to recognise and respond to inappropriate behaviour. Review how employees can raise concerns and whether complaints are recorded and investigated properly. Businesses dealing directly with customers, contractors and other third parties should also consider situations in which their employees could experience inappropriate behaviour from people outside the organisation. Training may be appropriate, particularly for managers and supervisors.

Employment law is continuing to change, and businesses do not need to become experts in every new provision. They do, however, need procedures that reflect their responsibilities. A useful starting point is therefore to review employment policies, management training and record-keeping arrangements before the October changes take effect.

Training clawbacks can constitute an unlawful restraint of trade

Seeking to claw back training costs from wages is common practice. However, a recent ruling has set clearer boundaries as to how this can become an unenforceable restraint of trade. An appellant joined an IT services provider as a trainee quality assurance engineer and entered into an employment contract alongside a separate “contract of training investment” which levied a “training cost debt” of over £8,000 for mentoring and internal support.

Under the scheme, this debt would gradually be ‘paid off’ if the claimant remained with the company, although if his employment were to be terminated for any reason other than redundancy, the remaining balance was to become immediately recoverable.

The appellant resigned after 8 months to accept a better-paid role elsewhere, prompting the employer to initiate legal proceedings to recover the full sum. After initial setbacks, the appellant took his case to the Court of Appeal, arguing that such a clawback scheme constituted an unlawful restraint of trade.

The Court unanimously allowed the appeal, setting aside the previous judgements and firmly rejecting the employer’s argument that an unconditional repayment obligation falls beyond the restraint of trade doctrine, as it was framed as a debt. Such financial penalties and liabilities effectively create an indirect restraint by acting as a powerful deterrent against changing employers.

The contractual clauses failed as the pernicious repayment obligation applied, regardless of the reason for departure, and were written irrespective of whether the employee moved to a higher-paid job in the same sector or left the workforce entirely. This decision has significant implications for employment law and HR practice, particularly for how organisations structure training arrangements, financial incentives, and employee retention mechanisms.

Reframing clawbacks as commercial debts rather than as traditional post-termination restrictive covenants no longer confers immunity from the doctrine of restraint of trade, and employers can no longer rely on such universal and indiscriminate repayment clauses. To be enforceable, a clawback provision must be carefully tailored and may not impose heavy financial liabilities on junior staff who are paid at or near minimum wage. From this point, employers must ensure that any training cost recovery schemes are proportionate, reflect any value already returned to the business, and do not unduly restrict an individual’s freedom to change employment.

When a discretionary bonus becomes enforceable

Where an employee is promised a discretionary bonus as an incentive, an employer may be held liable for the full figure if the preconditions have been met and the chain of authorisation is fully satisfied. Indeed, a recent ruling by a tribunal has made it clear that employers cannot unilaterally alter the preconditions or quantum of a bonus once the agreed terms have been met and approved.

The contention arose after a global cloud hosting platform introduced a bonus incentive scheme, which, according to the presentation slide deck, offered sales staff a discretionary bonus of “up to 1%” of revenues derived from invoicing any new client over the first twelve months of the contract, subject to the approval of the Sector Lead Head (SLH). Soon after this offer was made, the claimant secured a major contract with a prominent retailer, whereupon the line manager formally emailed the SLH to recommend the full 1% commission. The SLH duly authorised the bonus in a recorded ‘memo’. However, the senior management baulked at the prospective payout of £516,082 and sought to retroactively apply a £150,000 bonus cap. While the initial claim for the unlawful deduction of wages was dismissed on the ground that no legal entitlement had crystallised, this was overturned on appeal, as the objective terms of the bonus scheme had been clearly outlined, met, and approved by the designated authority.

Crucially, once the SLH had authorised the bonus, the claimant’s entitlement to 1% of the first year’s revenues had legally materialised, and the employer had no legal right to cap the bonus or insist upon additional management sign-offs. Thus, discretionary bonus schemes do not automatically grant employers unrestricted authority to alter payment terms at their whim, as, once an employer has established a discretionary bonus framework, communicates its specific terms to an employee, and subsequently exercises its discretion to approve the award, a binding legal obligation has been formed. As a consequence of this landmark ruling, employers should review all bonus incentive schemes to ensure that they do not inadvertently create any unanticipated obligations.

Have you reviewed your workers’ employment status?

Businesses should regularly review whether individuals working for them are correctly classified as employees, workers or self-employed. Getting employment status wrong can result in unexpected tax liabilities, penalties and loss of employment rights.

Employment status affects both the rights of the individual and the responsibilities of the business. However, a person’s employment status for employment law purposes may differ from their status for tax purposes, so employers need to consider both.

An employee usually works under an employment contract and has greater employment rights, including protection against unfair dismissal, subject to qualifying conditions, and entitlement to statutory payments.

A self-employed person generally runs their own business, takes responsibility for its success or failure and is responsible for their own tax and National Insurance obligations. However, the label used in a contract is not enough on its own. HMRC and employment tribunals will consider the actual working relationship.

Factors that may indicate employment include regular working hours, supervision and control by the business, the provision of equipment and the inability to send someone else to carry out the work.

Businesses should use HMRC’s employment status checking tool, Check employment status for tax (CEST), where appropriate. The CEST tool gives HMRC’s view of a worker’s employment status, based on the information provided.

All online harassment is unacceptable, in any context

A recent ruling has determined that targeting individuals online, even on a private group chat, can lead to a loss of employment. A Mr. Y was employed by the Royal Mail as a delivery driver with an impeccable, longstanding record of service. This was not to last as, in 2022, a labour dispute orchestrated by his union led to the creation of a messaging group for all union members at his depot.

While Mr. Y held no formal office or role within his union, he remained an active member and his strength of feeling led him to post two highly controversial messages on the group chat. The first was a direct expletive aimed at their employer, albeit one accompanied by an ‘only joking’ emoji. The second, however, constituted a significant escalation, as Mr. Y called out two colleagues who had opted not to participate in the strike, demanding their allegiance and jesting that the failure to join their ranks would result in their ‘cars being blown up’.

Mr. Y subsequently apologised and maintained that he had been joking. However, a trainee manager who had been sent the post considered it genuinely intimidating. This led to a formal internal investigation by the Royal Mail, which found that the posts directly breached their code of corporate conduct and social media policies regarding threatening behaviour toward colleagues, leading to Mr. Y’s immediate dismissal for gross misconduct. In response, Mr. Y launched a legal claim, arguing that his dismissal was automatically unfair, as his messages fell within the auspices of protected trade union activities.

The Employment Tribunal rejected his claim, reaffirming the company’s finding of misconduct. Mr. Y then took his case to an Employment Appeal Tribunal. The Appeals Judge, however, upheld the Lower Tribunal’s finding that legal protections for union activities do not extend to abusive or threatening language merely because it takes place within a union-branded forum. The Judge concurred that such profanity did not advance any union aims and that any message intimating violence transcended peaceful and lawful industrial encouragement. Moreover, the Tribunal did not need to decide whether the message was intended as a genuine threat or as a joke, as both would engender an atmosphere of menace that breached any statutory protection.

This ruling sends an unambiguous warning that messaging platforms, including ‘private’ group chats, are not legally insulated spaces. This case draws a clear demarcation between any vigorous advocacy for lawful union action and targeting colleagues with hostile rhetoric. Any attempts to ‘pressure’ coworkers with threats of violence, no matter how they are intimated, carry severe professional risk. For employers, this may signal that their purview extends to any private group chats among their employees, should their attention be drawn to any problematic messages, and not merely internal Emails or messaging forums such as Slack and Teams.

Take care when painting non-compete clauses with a broad brush

Protecting hard-won local customer networks is a constant and necessary battle for commercial suppliers. However, a recent High Court judgement has exposed the risks inherent in employing standard ‘boilerplate’ contracts to restrict departing sales staff. The dispute in focus was triggered when a national building supplies merchant sought final injunctions against its former area sales manager. Under the terms of his contract, the defendant was defined as a peripatetic area sales manager responsible for high-value client accounts across the local regions. The contract was subject to a standard one-week notice period during a probationary window, yet also contained extensive post-termination restrictions, including a 6-month, geographically defined non-compete covenant, alongside a 12-month confidentiality clause.

During the course of his employment, the defendant had regular access to the merchant’s digital management systems, which record customer transaction histories, pipeline projects, and a variable pricing hierarchy. Some months later, the defendant resigned from the merchant under the presumed obligation of three months’ notice with a view to joining a direct competitor as an external sales manager to help launch their new regional branch.

The defendant’s previous company learned that regional clients on the departing manager’s sales ledger were being actively engaged. Specifically, the merchant referenced a professional networking exchange between the defendant and a buyer for a prominent local construction company, during which the defendant directed the buyer’s representative to reroute quotes through his new employer. Fearing an immediate loss of its localised trade connections, the merchant issued a formal legal claim and successfully secured an interim injunction to enforce both the 6-month non-compete covenant and a temporary confidentiality restriction.

The High Court, however, dismissed the employer’s claims, declaring the non-compete covenant void and unenforceable, while further rejecting the application for a final confidentiality injunction. The Judge’s assessment focused on fatal drafting flaws in the agreement, specifically the dismantling of a contractual “carve-out” intended to allow the employee to work in non-competing areas. Moreover, the former employer attempted a belated “blue-pencil” deletion to alter this exception. However, the High Court ruled that an employer cannot retroactively rewrite a relaxation clause to limit a former employee’s freedom.

The High Court also applied the “Quilter point,” confirming that, as the manager could have been dismissed at a week’s notice during his initial probation period, applying an immediate 6-month blanket ban from ‘day one’ was fundamentally disproportionate. Finally, the Court ruled that the pricing schedules listed on the company’s internal software were merely artificial screen prices. Given that genuine commodity prices fluctuate rapidly due to global market forces, regional builders routinely and openly share competitor quotes to drive down costs. Thus, the departing manager possessed no memorable or stable trade secrets which could have been unlawfully exploited.

If boilerplate trade protections are structurally inconsistent, geographically bloated, or syntactically flawed, they will be struck down entirely under employment law, leaving client databases open to exploitation. A non-competition restriction is only as strong as the internal consistency of your wider framework, and seeking to retroactively expand a post-termination boundary to include marginal outlier accounts will likely backfire.

If an organisation reserves the right to terminate an introductory employee at a week’s notice, any attempt to lock that individual out of the job market for 6 months will likely be viewed as an unlawful restraint of trade, and so corporate counsel must structure agreements using variable, ascending tiers of restriction that directly correspond to the employee’s actual length of service and seniority.

Book a call

Twenty minutes, no charge

Tell us when to ring and a little about the job. Someone from the practice will call you back, usually the same working day.

Fields marked * are required

Ask a question

Ask us anything

A sentence or two is enough. We will reply by email, usually the same working day.

Fields marked * are required